home > Jackblog > Barbour> Crime> domestic violence> State> ladd

Barbour Pardons Helped Many More Whites Than Blacks

I'm sure this will come as a surprise to no one, but it's official: Haley Barbour's last-minute pardons overwhelmingly benefitted whites. A Reuters team, including stringer and JFP political freelancer Robbie Ward, analyzed the race of the criminals on the list and found that although blacks represent more than two-thirds of MIssissippi's prison population, fewer than a third of Barbour's pardonees were black:

Former Mississippi Governor Haley Barbour's grants of commutations or pardons to more than 200 prisoners, all but eight in his final days in office, disproportionately benefited white offenders among a predominantly black prison population, a Reuters analysis found. [...]

Regardless of the underlying reason, such a disparity between the racial background of those pardoned and prison demographics is a significant statistical anomaly, according to University of Georgia statisticians Kim Love-Myers and Jaxk Reeves, who carried out an analysis of the data for Reuters.

"This type of observational information cannot prove causality, though it does indicate a significant relationship between race and the probability of being pardoned," Love-Myers wrote in an email.

"The odds of a random sample of the prison population coming out with the same or greater disparity in racial proportions as the pardons list is less than one in a trillion, if race were truly unrelated to pardons."[/url]

It's a great piece. Cheers to Robbie and the rest of the Reuters team.

 
posted by DonnaLadd on 01/20/12 at 07:30 PM. [printer version]    Share |

COMMENTS

Don't see how the racial make up of the prison population has anything to with the racial make up of those pardoned, since most 180 of the people not in jail or under supervision of the prison system. They also forgot to mention the 3 out of the 5 murders and armed robber that worked at the Gov house were black. If race placed any part in it, why how that happen.

Like the article said people have to ASK for a pardon,just because blacks don't, doesn't mean that more white people being pardoned is racist,it just mean they did ask for them, that is their fault,nobody else's has nothing to do with race.

posted by BubbaT on 01/20/12 at 08:17 PM

A few random responses, Bubba:

Robbie said they've had a difficult time getting info on who requested pardons and which were turned down, so that is an unknown factor as of now (and addressed int he Reuters article).

In 2008, the pardons trustys were white, and we called that out; it is quite possible that Barbour decided to include the black ones this time around to take care of that little issue.

Whether they're still in jail is a smokescreen thrown up by Barbour. Still being in jail is far from the only issue: felon access to guns is huge, as is who gets the chance to vote again.

Another question is how many are helped when it comes to pardons and such.

Bottom line: You don't have any idea whether it had to do with race or not, although you *always* kneejerk into saying it doesn't.

Bottom line 2: Barbour's willingness to grant pardons to that many white men is an issue as well. I doubt that anyone things he would have granted more than 200 pardons had all or the vast majority of them been black.

He won't even pardon the Scott Sisters, which is patently absurd.

posted by DonnaLadd on 01/20/12 at 08:48 PM

Oops hit send before I proof read. :)

Should have been last paragraph should have said
"Like the article said people have to ASk for a pardon,just because blacks don't, doesn't mean more white people being pardoned is racist it just means blacks didn't ask for them, that is their fault, nobody else's, has nothe to do with race."

posted by BubbaT on 01/20/12 at 08:52 PM

Donna- You don't have any idea whether race played a part in it either,now do you? You seem to think everyone makes their decisions based of race, when they don't.

Just because more whites were doesn't mean race had to do with any part of it. Like the article said,the race of the person isn't even included in the pardon recommendation from the parol board nor the ex-prisoners request. So the race of the 69 that were turned down doesn't matter. Hard for race to play a part in the pardon decisions if you don't know their race, don't you think

Don't you have to accept the guilt or not contest your verdict to get a pardon from the Gov?, you do for a Pres. pardon I am fairly sure, maybe if the Scott sister would admit their guilty instead of falsely claiming innocence they might get a pardon. Just a thought.

As for the trusty/murders he pardoned, I think they should have been excuted a long time ago, that would have solved this litte pardon gate thing before it ever happened.

posted by BubbaT on 01/20/12 at 09:09 PM

It would be interesting to know what the racial makeup is of the list of people who actually followed the rules and will actually get their pardon instead of the dimwits who screwed it up and now get the finger from Jim Hood. It is interesting that a lot of people who were involved in the business end of the drug trade managed to cross their t's and dot all their i's. A little jail time to clear their head and they get their act together.

There was a report not too long ago, I can't remember where (NPR maybe), about Bush's pardons. They also were heavily skewed towards whites. The selection process was colorblind in that the selectors had no way of knowing the race of the applicant. It was very interesting also.

posted by WMartin on 01/20/12 at 10:12 PM

Bubba T. Please give this issue up!! Your statement about not seeing what race has to do with the number of pardons issued by Former Gov. Haley Barbour is at best, RIDICULOUS!

posted by justjess on 01/21/12 at 08:00 PM

Jess- Nope, not gonna happen, till someone offers up some PROOF race played a part in the pardons.Until then anything Reuters and JFP prints on the subject is just assumptions based on no facts. Comparing ratios of the prison and state population to the pardons is grasping for straws and useless. Just because the numbers don't add up for them doesn't prove that the pardons were granted because of race.

posted by BubbaT on 01/21/12 at 11:33 PM

Page 1 of 1 pages

You are not logged in. To post a comment, you must be a registered user and logged in. Click here to register or click here to log in.

Log in to JFP using Facebook

:: recentcomments

May 23, 2012 | 01:37 PM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
golden eagle: Wow, my English was bad on the previous post. You know how it is on these iPhones.
May 23, 2012 | 12:30 PM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
golden eagle: @Jess, I think the word you're looking for is "assassination". @Darryl, do we really know that the majority of MS'ians wanted this, when you consider that this was a ...
May 23, 2012 | 12:18 PM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
DonnaLadd: I can only hope that the reason that this bill passed is that, for once, our lawmakers listened to the majority of Mississippians and crafted this bill. Considering that the ...
May 23, 2012 | 11:57 AM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
justjess: @Darryl 5/23 "....for once, our lawmakers listened to the majority of Mississippians and crafted this bill." My question is still on the table: What were you "majority ...
May 23, 2012 | 05:26 AM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
Darryl: justjess, I can only hope that the reason that this bill passed is that, for once, our lawmakers listened to the majority of Mississippians and crafted this bill. But, recall, that ...
May 22, 2012 | 04:26 PM
One Night at Fenian's
DonnaLadd: ... because if there is anything The Clarion-Ledger can muster the resources to do, it's show up any night of the week and take drunk pictures. Meantime, they crib our sports stories. ...
May 22, 2012 | 03:53 PM
One Night at Fenian's
Rico: Next time just call Metro Mix at the C-L and have them come and take some pretty pictures for the newspaper. Hell, the got some on karaoke night Monday.
May 22, 2012 | 02:07 PM
[Editorial] To Do Its Job, Council Must Show Up
RobbieR: And Chokwe wants to run for Mayor? Hopefully the citizens of Jackson don't fall for this clown's rhetoric.
May 22, 2012 | 01:15 PM
Catholics Sue Over Birth Control Rule
Brian C Johnson: I cannot decide whether this is a vanity lawsuit, in the sense that the bishops know they stand little chance of prevailing in court. Or to put it more charitably, ...
May 22, 2012 | 01:00 PM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
Brian C Johnson: Darryl, I think it is simply a statement of fact that African Americans in Mississippi are less likely to have the required photo ID. If so, the new law is discriminatory in ...
May 22, 2012 | 11:25 AM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
Duan C.: I am in agreement with Golden Eagle - requiring I.D. ties a fee into voting, the only reason why its considered "discriminatory" towards black, is because it places back into an era ...
May 22, 2012 | 10:22 AM
Person of the Day: Rep. Andy Gipson
RobbieR: What? I was clearly referring to Bennie Thompson, not Rep. Gipson. Rep. Bennie Thomson represents Mississippi's 2nd Congressional district; Darryl noted that he rep'd the ...
May 22, 2012 | 09:59 AM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
justjess: Darryl, out of my "simple ignorance" I ask you this "little question:" Why are registered voters here in the State of Mississippi being asked to produce a picture ID? When the State ...
May 22, 2012 | 08:49 AM
Person of the Day: Rep. Andy Gipson
Duan C.: @ Robbie R - you lost me on that one? They have him listed in the 77th District - covering Rankin, Simpson, and Smith counties?
May 22, 2012 | 08:47 AM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
bill_jackson: I would be interested to know what percentage of the voting age population does not have identification in this day and age.

100 recent comments »

 


click to view "flip" version of this week's print issue

 

Guests online: 269
Logged-in members: 1
Anonymous members: 1
Elapsed time: 1.1419
The most number of visitors ever was 1961 at once on 03/27/2012
currently online: golden eagle

 

© Jackson Free Press, Inc. - portions of code by CC with EE. User agreement and privacy statement.
phone: 601-362-6121 (ext 11 sales, ext 16 editorial, ext 17 publisher)
fax: 601-510-9019 * P.O. Box 5067 * Jackson, MS * 39296