home > Noise > City/County> Melton> Politics

Melton: ‘How Dumb Can You Be?’


Jaro Vacek/file photo
Mayor Frank Melton had his way in court today in a battle to stay on the Democratic ballot for mayor.

by Adam Lynch
March 25, 2009

Jones County Circuit Court Judge Billy Joe Landrum gave Jackson Mayor Frank Melton the keys to the courtroom at a hearing today, allowing him to belligerently insult the attorney for the Democratic committee that expelled him from the primary ballot last week and avoid answering questions he did not wish to address. Landrum has been put in charge of a suit to decide whether or not Melton can legally run for re-election as a Democrat.

The Jackson Municipal Democratic Executive Committee voted unanimously to remove Melton from the primary ballot after reviewing Nexis/Lexis records on his driver’s license and Hinds County tax information revealing that Melton again filed for a homestead exemption at his Texas home, rather than in Jackson.

The committee argues that Melton does not qualify to run in the election because he is not a Jackson resident.

Landrum impatiently complained of eye operations, health exams and a busy schedule, but said he would fax his decision on the matter by 5 p.m. tomorrow. Judging by his handling of the hearing, however, the committee has little reason to suspect he will rule in their favor.

Melton’s attitude toward defense attorney Dorsey Carson was dismissive and oftentimes difficult throughout the course of his time on the witness stand. The mayor happily provided information regarding utility bills and driver’s license information supporting his Jackson residency, but evaded questions concerning his honesty before the committee in 2005 and his federal tax information, with Landrum’s blessing.

“On your federal income taxes do you claim Texas or Mississippi as your domicile?” Carson asked.

“We don’t claim either one of them,” Melton answered.

“There’s a form where you have to list your address,” the attorney pointed out.

“You’ll have to ask (my accountant).”

“You do not know what state in which you list your taxes?”

“They give you a number. I’m not a tax expert.”

“You don’t know the address that you and your wife put on your federal taxes?” Carson persisted.

“No, sir,” Melton answered, but added “I’m just embarrassed at the waste of this court’s time.”

Committee members claim Melton’s residency could be a sticking point. In order for Melton and his wife—who file federal taxes jointly—to claim a Texas homestead exemption, both must swear that the Texas address is a “primary residence.”

If this is true, Melton likely lists his status at his Jackson address as “part-time resident.”

Landrum seemed dismissive of Melton’s refusal to answer.

“Look, he says he doesn’t know. I don’t fill out my own income taxes,” the judge said, and added that he would tell the counselor to file a request for Melton’s partially redacted federal tax information before noon tomorrow.

The judge did not seem to mind Melton disparaging Carson from the witness stand. At one point, Carson asked Melton to confirm if he had recovered from a recent operation in Texas rather than Mississippi, whereas Melton replied, “How dumb can you be?”

Landrum condoned Melton’s attitude, ordering the attorney to move on to other questions that the witness could ignore, such as Carson’s inquiry about the residency of the children that Melton had legally adopted.

“I’m going to protect them, and I just don’t think that’s your business,” Melton answered.

The Jackson Free Press reported in 2005 that Melton had told committee members that he had filed for a homestead exemption for his Jackson residence, and—weeks later—it reported the response from Melton’s attorney Sarah O’Reilly-Evans when the truth about Melton’s misinformation reached the committee.

O’Reilly-Evans told the committee at that time that they could do nothing about Melton’s lie because the window of time to act upon it had passed.

Today, Melton denied any knowledge of misleading the committee, despite numerous witness accounts.

Landrum felt Carson’s line of questioning on the matter meant nothing to the case, however.

When asked why the committee had accepted Melton’s claim in 2005 without verification, committee President Claude McInnis said they had no reason to doubt him: “We did not know at the time that Melton had a propensity for dishonesty,” McInnis said.

Melton’s attorney John Reeves said the committee is basing their rejection of Melton’s place on the ballot upon too narrow a definition, and appeared confident that he would win the case.

“Where you file for homestead exemption is only one factor,” Reeves told reporters. “People have more than one residence, so the Supreme Court has ruled that you can prove where you live by a number of factors, not just homestead exemption.”

 
posted by DonnaLadd on 03/25/09 at 05:45 PM. [printer version]    Share |

COMMENTS

Joseph Pleasant of WAPT was asking Melton a question as they were walking on a downtown street and Melton told him, "Why don't you stand on the street til the 18-wheeler truck come?" Sigh.

posted by golden eagle on 03/25/09 at 06:10 PM

No matter how many accountants you have doing your taxes, you still have to sign the forms. It's pretty dumb to sign anything without reading it, but apparently Melton does and so does Landrum since he thinks it understandable Melton doesn't know the address on the tax form. I guess that just makes both of them, well, dumb.

posted by chaffeur on 03/25/09 at 06:34 PM

WTF - somebody needs to question Chief Justice Waller why the heck he appointed a known political hack judge. This is the same judge that was involved in all of the controversial tobacco cases, where he constantly sided with Scruggs, et al.

Sounds to me like the fix is already in. Geez, When will we ever get a break here in Jackson. I don't know which way this case OUGHT to go, but I sure wish I had more confidence in the legal system to do the right thing and have confidence that a legitimate, well-reasoned, and proper decision is being made.

posted by FriendsofJackson on 03/25/09 at 07:16 PM

I keep saying... The courts aren't going to help Jackson.

posted by Ironghost on 03/25/09 at 08:14 PM

It is someone in the Supreme Court that keeps appointing Judges who favor Melton. This one seems to be even more biased, if that is possible. His comment to the WAPT reporter is just a small example of what his swagger will be if someone does not stop him. The law means nothing. Playing the game on the edge means everything to him.

Nice job of giving us some flavor in this article, Adam.

posted by Razor on 03/25/09 at 09:16 PM

You're right Ironghost. The courts aren't going to help Jackson. The fix is in. Melton's name will be placed back on the ballot. This is so very sad.

posted by blu_n_a_redstate on 03/25/09 at 09:42 PM

Melton was never "on the ballot". He was seeking placement on the ballot as a Democrat. The Democratic Party has a right to determine who they want to represent the party. Why didn't he run as an independent since he didn't like either party?

posted by CatO9tails on 03/25/09 at 10:49 PM

Melton's on it. Jackson is doomed.

posted by Ironghost on 03/26/09 at 11:21 AM

Surprise, surprise! Judge must have flipped a two-headed coin at lunch.

posted by Razor on 03/26/09 at 11:39 AM

How is Jackson doomed? I'm not voting for Melton, but I think it was the right call. He does live in Jackson.

posted by golden eagle on 03/26/09 at 12:33 PM

Because good people will obey the law, even if it says "Jump off a Cliff". People like Melton will ignore the sign and laugh at the idiots who obey the law. Melton has never suffered for disobeying the law, so by now he sees no point in doing so. Now he can take advantage of those who will try to obey the law.

posted by Ironghost on 03/26/09 at 12:36 PM

CatO9tails, not only didn't melton "like either party", he was not a registered voter until he ran for the office of mayor. There is no history of his being a registered voter in Texas. There has never been an official background check and everything that was checked (use of fire arms) turned out to be a lie.

I am glad that the Judge ruled to have melton placed on the ballot. The Democratic Executive Committee, as well as some others, could have challenged melton's residency issues four years ago.

You let this man serve as the mayor of the city for four years and now the committee is saying that he doesn't live here? This is STUPID! What is even more DUMB is Musgrove appointing him as Director of the MBN. He did nothing there but ruin the lives of others. By the way, he worked without pay, so, Musgrove did not order a background check. This guy, melton, is a master at game playing.

The JFP tried to keep this community informed; however, the fast talking, lying, and unethical colorful melton would win over reason.

I am not a melton fan and I have tried to tell folks that melton was nothing but sound bites for certain media (CL) and that his lies were so thin that Ray Charles and Stevie Wonder saw all of them on the same day.

If his name is on the ballot, the people will decide. If he is VOTED OUT, his game is over. This is an important election and I hope that citizens will not be fooled again.

posted by justjess on 03/26/09 at 12:48 PM

Justess,

The issue was not if he could be on the ballot.

The issue was would he be listed as a Democratic on the ballot. Last time (4 years ago) the challenge to his residency was filed too late to prevent him from running as a Democrat.

This time, the challenge to Melton's residency was filed too late for Melton to respond to the challenge in time to run as an independent or Republican.

The R's surely would have done the same thing the D's did in challenging his residency, and in my opinion the Jones County judge would have upheld the R's refusal, think Mississippi Burning.

I am amazed how people don't realize that when you allow the little despots to ignore the law at their leisure, you give the medium sized despots (Ed Peters and Dickie Scruggs) and the big despots (Bush and Chaney), the cover to do the same...or visa versa, take your pick.

It's the old broken window-dirty lot, broken tail light postulate. If you allow the little things to pass, in no time the big things are allowed to pass as well.

Mayor Hawkins has shown the counter-viability of such a philosophy in Madison, in her own despotic, yet charming way.

PS: If the D's were serious they would appeal the Jones decision all the way up to the Ms supreme court. By then the election would be over...see also Bush-Cheny 2000.

posted by FrankMickens on 03/26/09 at 01:54 PM

It's called the Dirty South for a reason, and it's not because of the way we dance or how often we wash our cars.

That said, Melton's odds of winning are pretty low whether he's on the ballot or not. Even if he somehow makes the runoff (and he's polling fifth place in the stuff I've seen), how likely is he to get 51% when he's got another federal trial coming up mere days later?

Incumbency isn't necessarily a huge advantage for mayors, particularly bad mayors. I have faith in the people of Jackson and I don't expect Melton to get reelected.

posted by Tom Head on 03/26/09 at 03:02 PM

My faith is surging... I feel a little better about Jackson every day. I have no doubt we'll have a new mayor.

posted by Tom Head on 03/26/09 at 03:20 PM

baquan2000, If melton is re-elected, after I dry my eyes, the FIRST thing I will do is to contact Harvey and his family to express my deep sorrow because they are just good, honest, decent folks and Harvey has the experience, the training and a wealth of knowledge to manage this city. He also takes community development with "INCLUSION" to another level.

NEXT, I will ask you to disclose your idenity and meet me for a sit on the front steps of City Hall. This is where we will conduct our laughing contest. I know for a fact I will win.

And please, no comments about insensitivity. Laughter would be the only emotion left.

posted by justjess on 03/26/09 at 03:36 PM

what polls u saw wat websites

posted by NewJackson on 03/26/09 at 03:39 PM

NewJack, I can't remember offhand but in one he was polling at 9%, and in another somewhere between 10 and 15%.

posted by Tom Head on 03/26/09 at 04:02 PM

My own gut instinct thought that Melton would only poll around 10%, plus or minus a few points.

posted by golden eagle on 03/26/09 at 04:16 PM

I have trouble believing the majority of Jacksonians are so irredeemably stupid as to re-elect Meltdown based on his record. Five to ten percent would maybe.

And I agree with the judge's decision. Since Meltdown was allowed to run last time as a Demorat despite his shaky residency eligibility he should be allowed to run as one this time.

posted by Jeff Lucas on 03/26/09 at 06:28 PM

You never lose betting on someone's stupidity. I bet they'll go for Melton again.

posted by Ironghost on 03/26/09 at 08:22 PM

Okay, so how much you wanna bet?

posted by Tom Head on 03/26/09 at 08:27 PM

yeah put me down for twenty meltons out

posted by NewJackson on 03/27/09 at 07:02 AM

Given the current economy, you'd be lucky to get a dollar out of me, Tom. :)

posted by Ironghost on 03/27/09 at 08:56 AM

Page 1 of 1 pages

You are not logged in. To post a comment, you must be a registered user and logged in. Click here to register or click here to log in.

Log in to JFP using Facebook

:: recentcomments

May 25, 2012 | 02:20 PM
JRA Says Ugly Garage Ramp Must Go
justjess: Not a problem and for sure, not a priority. In an ecomomy where people are concerned about the State's infrastructure (unstable bridges, sreets in desperate need of repair ...
May 25, 2012 | 02:17 PM
BREAKING: JPS Agrees to Overhaul Discipline Policies, Settles Lawsuit
lizwaibel: Also today, the US Dept. of Education released a resource document that says restraint or seclusion does not reduce the occurrence of ...
May 25, 2012 | 09:32 AM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
notmuch: I'm not sure where the "@" came from, but I think golden eagle's response was directed to me, so I will respond one more time. First, the inclusion of the word "facts" and the phrase ...
May 25, 2012 | 08:01 AM
[Dish] Cobby Williams, Young Gun
Queen601: That first question is classic! LOL
May 24, 2012 | 09:34 PM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
golden eagle: @notmuch, here are some facts about voter fraud, straight from the Brennan Center's website: Fraud by individual voters is both irrational and extremely rare. Most citizens who ...
May 24, 2012 | 07:14 PM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
notmuch: Oh, I have hundreds of those right-wing sites, and I couldn't say which ones are more "partisan"--they all include those pesky facts. Yes, when dead voters and multiple voters under ...
May 24, 2012 | 07:11 PM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
justjess: @ golden eagle. Thanks for the spell check. I didn't just spell assassination wrong ONE time, I did it over and over. LOL! You are right on the mark; I was trying to use the word ...
May 24, 2012 | 06:46 PM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
golden eagle: I don't think you could've found a more partisan right-wing site than the Daily Caller. The fact of the matter is that the right is using this issue not as a means of improving ...
May 24, 2012 | 06:10 PM
[Dish] Cobby Williams, Young Gun
trusip: WOW! was this a real interview or a joke?
May 24, 2012 | 05:00 PM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
notmuch: I don't think you could have found a more liberal example of a "non-partisan" site, but even so, their evidence seems to consist of 250 carefully chosen instances in one area of ...
May 24, 2012 | 04:48 PM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
golden eagle: Rather than using ideological websites to support your argument, I'll use the non-partisan Brennan Center for Justice. Really good site.
May 24, 2012 | 04:30 PM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
notmuch: I might be missing something here, but I am a little confused by Golden Eagle's points: "the fact is that voter fraud is extremely rare"--so it is of no consequence that some ...
May 24, 2012 | 11:26 AM
Nick Hanauer's 'Controversial' TED Talk -- Tax the Rich?
RobbieR: TED is an elite academic conference.
May 24, 2012 | 10:18 AM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
DonnaLadd: No, Darryl, no one blocked you. Stop being paranoid. We just typically open comments in moderation during non-office hours. To me, a bozo isn't someone who disagrees with me. It's ...
May 24, 2012 | 06:18 AM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
Darryl: That's funny that you blocked my last comment...

100 recent comments »

 


click to view "flip" version of this week's print issue

 

Guests online: 193
Logged-in members: 0
Anonymous members: 0
Elapsed time: 0.9882
The most number of visitors ever was 1961 at once on 03/27/2012

 

© Jackson Free Press, Inc. - portions of code by CC with EE. User agreement and privacy statement.
phone: 601-362-6121 (ext 11 sales, ext 16 editorial, ext 17 publisher)
fax: 601-510-9019 * P.O. Box 5067 * Jackson, MS * 39296