home > Noise > domestic violence

Domestic Abuse is a Pre-Existing Condition in Mississippi


File Photo
Insurance Commissioner Mike Chaney says the legislature should mandate coverage of domestic abuse so that insurance companies cannot categorize it as a pre-existing condition.

by Adam Lynch
September 16, 2009

Mississippi Insurance Commissioner Mike Chaney expressed outrage today that the state of Mississippi is one of eight states in the nation, including the District of Columbia, which allows insurance companies to consider domestic abuse as a pre-existing condition with which to deny health-care coverage. The National Women's Law Center reported in April that the state of Arkansas passed a law prohibiting insurance companies to pull coverage for domestic violence survivors, putting a spotlight on the remaining states.

"The truth is we've got eight states in the union that count domestic abuse as a pre-existing condition, and Mississippi is one of them," Chaney told the Jackson Free Press. "I've got to get some of my lawyers to do some research on this, but we have only six mandated (conditions that must be covered) in our state statues, and we have 25 or more optional coverages, but domestic abuse doesn't seem to be one of them."

Chaney said all insurance companies in the state can take advantage of the state's limited coverage mandate, and that he would prefer the state to change its law to force insurance companies to cover victims of domestic abuse.

"Would I do something about it? Hell, yeah, I'd do something about it, but I'm a regulator, not a legislator. I have to come to terms with that every week," Chaney said. "The whole situation is bad. Let's say a woman works with a company that had Blue Cross/Blue Shield, and she gets beat up in her house and Blue Cross says 'we're not covering you because getting beat up is your pre-existing condition.' That's terrible."

Chaney explained that the law has to be changed at the Legislature: "They would have to change the statute to say that spousal abuse is a mandated coverage. We've done it before when we added coverage for mammograms and some other things."

Sen. Dean Kirby, R-Pearl, served as chair of the Senate's Insurance Committee before moving to the Finance Committee, where he has served as chairman for two years. Kirby said the state law on the issue surprised him.

"I didn't even know we allowed for them to deny coverage due to domestic abuse," Kirby said. "I wonder how long that's been on the books, because I certainly didn't pass it, and I've been on the committee for 12 years," Kirby said. "I would think that the chairman of the insurance committees in the House and Senate would consider seriously changing that law."

Senate Insurance Chairman Eugene Clarke, R-Hollandale, and House Insurance Chairman Walker Robinson, D-Bolton, could not immediately be reached for comment.

Kirby, who is a property and casualty insurance agent, said he did not think a state law change would impact insurance companies significantly.

"I can't see it making a lot of difference in the premium, and I think the legislature should really consider changing it," Kirby said. "I can't imagine there being so much domestic abuse that they would consider exempting it. I think the companies are probably paying for it and don't even realize that it qualifies as a pre-existing condition."

 
posted by .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) on 09/16/09 at 12:15 PM. [printer version]    Share |

COMMENTS

This is difficult to comprehend. Why would the insurance company do something like this? Trying to force people out of abusive relationships?
If somebody lives in a high crime neighborhood, will they still cover medical treatment after muggings? Are they excluding medical care related to high risk sports as well, like mountain climbing or hang gliding? Will there be no coverage if somebody gets into a car accident while speeding or driving under the influence. Oh, hang on, most of the victims of domestic violence are women and we're already so expensive because we get ourselves pregnant. Gotta cut the cost where one can.

posted by RhinosMom on 09/16/09 at 01:53 PM

RhinosMom- They do it because they will most likely have to pay out more, not because they aren't trying to force anyone out of an abusive relationship.

This needs to fixed soon,I still think some senators and reps. need a old-fashion ass-whoppin over this, so they will no what it's like to be abused.

They do exclude medical coverage for high risk sports and even people who ride motorcycles instead of driving cars in some states.

posted by BubbaT on 09/16/09 at 05:37 PM

BubbaT, I agree that things need to change. I doubt changing the legislation will make much difference though. If states make a list of conditions that have to be covered, insurance companies will find other conditions to exclude. After all, there are quite a few folks who agree that some people should be charged more - thinking of smokers here and there has been discussion about obese people - so their premiums may go down. Where should one draw the line or should the line be drawn?

I am deeply concerned about the shift toward the bottom line and away from compassion and integrity in society in general. But I have a feeling that people have been concerned about just this thing for many generations and I'm not sure if things are really getting worse or if it is only perception. Still hoping we can be kinder to each other.

posted by RhinosMom on 09/17/09 at 09:08 AM

Insurance Commissioner Mike Chaney has submitted this clarification to the JFP about his statements in the above story. Verbatim:

“There have been recent articles and news stories which seem to imply that Mississippi, and the Mississippi Insurance Department in particular, allow insurance companies to deny coverage to and refuse to pay claims for victims of domestic violence. Such implication is patently untrue.

Mississippi does not at this time have a law which bans insurance companies from considering domestic violence as a pre-existing condition. However, the reason there is not such a law is that there has not been a problem with insurance companies denying coverage or refusing to pay the claims of domestic violence victims in this state. If it were an issue, the Legislature and the Department would have addressed it by now.

The Mississippi Department of Insurance is unaware of any insurance company operating in this state that would deny coverage if the applicant had been a victim of domestic violence. Nor have we received any complaint from a consumer stating their insurance company refused to pay their medical bills incurred from domestic violence. Such action by an insurance company would not be tolerated by the Department.

It is the position of the Department that if an insurance company denied payment of a claim incurred in an act of domestic violence, such action would be a violation of the Unfair Trade Practices Act, as promulgated in Miss. Code Ann. §§ 83-5-29 through 83-5-51, and the Department would take the appropriate action.

Should the Mississippi Legislature choose to enact legislation addressing this issue, the Mississippi Insurance Department would be very supportive of the passage of such legislation.”

—Mike Chaney

posted by DonnaLadd on 09/17/09 at 12:23 PM

Page 1 of 1 pages

You are not logged in. To post a comment, you must be a registered user and logged in. Click here to register or click here to log in.

Log in to JFP using Facebook

:: recentcomments

Feb 03, 2012 | 07:09 PM
Deuce Headed Back to Ole Miss, Reports Say
Todd Stauffer: Clarification: Now the Sun Herald tells us the Deuce thing isn't a done deal. So much for believing CoachingSearch.com. Also,"Mr. Factsy-pants" sports guy Bryan ...
Feb 03, 2012 | 05:52 PM
Is State Executing a Mentally Ill Man?
Ronni_Mott: Story is updated with the correct telephone number for the governor's office: 601-359-3150.
Feb 03, 2012 | 05:41 PM
[Kamikaze] 'I'm No Token'
Kamikaze: Renaldo, you may have hit the nail on the head. It could be perhaps in the differences in how Whites and Blacks deal w/ success. In affluence for White success stories there is a ...
Feb 03, 2012 | 04:58 PM
[Kamikaze] 'I'm No Token'
Renaldo Bryant: Good points Queen . I am not so sure that Whites have a mentality of “if I get it and you get it - WE KEEP IT” and blacks have the attitude of “if I get, I have to keep ...
Feb 03, 2012 | 03:41 PM
[Kamikaze] 'I'm No Token'
Queen601: Mr. Bryant, thanks for the dialogue and I agree with what you've shared. The "community" is really quick to turn their backs on those who move out of those neighborhoods and ...
Feb 03, 2012 | 03:01 PM
[Kamikaze] 'I'm No Token'
Renaldo Bryant: Good questions Kaze and Queen, I think much of the perception in many black communities about being “down” and the struggle comes from the sense of community that develops ...
Feb 03, 2012 | 02:19 PM
[Kamikaze] 'I'm No Token'
Kamikaze: And my wife poses a very good question. Why do Black feel like they need to see you struggle to know that youre "down"? Why is that if you 1. Have financial comfort you cant be "for" ...
Feb 03, 2012 | 02:15 PM
[Kamikaze] 'I'm No Token'
Kamikaze: Good discussion. And trust, its helping me as much as Im trying to help others in a similar quandry. Defining YOU for YOU may be the best mantra yet. Ive always fancied myself ...
Feb 03, 2012 | 12:03 PM
[Kamikaze] 'I'm No Token'
Queen601: "If I didn't define myself for myself, I would be crunched into other people's fantasies of me and eaten alive." Audre Lorde
Feb 03, 2012 | 11:13 AM
[Kamikaze] 'I'm No Token'
Renaldo Bryant: Very interesting topic. How to be a professional, "Down" Black man in 21st Century Jackson, MS. Somebody ought to write the book LOL!!! But seriously, this is a very good ...
Feb 03, 2012 | 10:32 AM
[Kamikaze] 'I'm No Token'
Duan C.: "Why the white folk need to see you in a suit and tie in order to believe you are "worthwhile" is beyond me?" Queen I caught that! lol!!!! Ok, you got me - you got me.
Feb 03, 2012 | 10:27 AM
Study: Race Affects Broadband Access
Duan C.: @ Renaldo - I was just trying to be under the radar with it - but you hit it on the head! lol!!! But you are right though
Feb 03, 2012 | 09:50 AM
Study: Race Affects Broadband Access
Renaldo Bryant: Actually Duan C, I saw the quote as indicative of the wealth gap between Black families and white families, not necessarily the companies charging black families ...
Feb 03, 2012 | 09:10 AM
[Kamikaze] 'I'm No Token'
Queen601: I met with a brother recently who has made the decision to remain poor (I guess poor is in the eye of the beholder because he would argue that he isn't poor). He has married himself ...
Feb 03, 2012 | 08:39 AM
[Kamikaze] 'I'm No Token'
Duan C.: "Worse still the black elite is scared as hell of ya because you threaten their "spot". Brotha, you hit the nail on the head with that one! The other two things I think we face are: ...

100 recent comments »

 


click to view "flip" version of this week's print issue

 

Guests online: 187
Logged-in members: 1
Anonymous members: 0
Elapsed time: 1.0687
The most number of visitors ever was 1380 at once on 04/28/2010
currently online: Kamikaze

 

© Jackson Free Press, Inc. - portions of code by CC with EE. User agreement and privacy statement.
phone: 601-362-6121 (ext 11 sales, ext 16 editorial, ext 17 publisher)
fax: 601-510-9019 * P.O. Box 5067 * Jackson, MS * 39296