home > Jackblog > ladd
Hey Palin: The ‘Death Panels’ Are Already Here, Darlin’
Over on Salon, Mike Madden responds to ex-Gov. Sarah Palin's latest idiocy, stating what should be obvious to all of us: The "death panels" are already here:
The future of healthcare in America, according to Sarah Palin, might look something like this: A sick 17-year-old girl needs a liver transplant. Doctors find an available organ, and they're ready to operate, but the bureaucracy -- or as Palin would put it, the "death panel" -- steps in and says it won't pay for the surgery. Despite protests from the girl's family and her doctors, the heartless hacks hold their ground for a critical 10 days. Eventually, under massive public pressure, they relent -- but the patient dies before the operation can proceed.
It certainly sounds scary enough to make you want to go show up at a town hall meeting and yell about how misguided President Obama's healthcare reform plans are. Except that's not the future of healthcare -- it's the present. Long before anyone started talking about government "death panels" or warning that Obama would have the government ration care, 17-year-old Nataline Sarkisyan, a leukemia patient from Glendale, Calif., died in December 2007, after her parents battled their insurance company, Cigna, over the surgery. Cigna initially refused to pay for it because the company's analysis showed Sarkisyan was already too sick from her leukemia; the liver transplant wouldn't have saved her life.
That kind of utilitarian rationing, of course, is exactly what Palin and other opponents of the healthcare reform proposals pending before Congress say they want to protect the country from. "Such a system is downright evil," Palin wrote, in the same message posted on Facebook where she raised the "death panel" specter. "Health care by definition involves life and death decisions."
COMMENTS
Read the whole story -- I heard some of these items on "The American Life" the other weekend and it's chilling. If nothing else happens with healthcare (insurance?) reform this session, it needs to be a more complete solution for people who don't have employer-supported policies.
I was freelance writer for 10 years before we started the JFP and had a helluva time being able to get and afford insurance, even thought I wasn't exactly on poverty wages and a book author, magazine writer and even a TV host for a few years. I had insurance through the national writer's union that was $500/mo for an individual and ridiculous stories like that (despite never even going to a doctor for about 10 years).
As we come out of this recession there's going to be more-and-more pressure for people to work for themselves, work as contractors, work freelance from home -- and we need solutions that allow not just poor folks, but professionals as well to have flexibility and affordability in their coverage.
posted by Todd Stauffer on 08/11/09 at 04:12 PM
The insurance companies run health care in america, along with the trial attorneys basically. The trial attorneys set what the standard of care is, and the insurance companies pay the least amount to stay out of the courtroom.
One thing to consider is most policies will have a lifetime cap on benefits, ie 1 million or 2 million dollars so if a treatment is proposed that exceeds that cap the patient is out of luck and while not a death panel per se it can sure smell like one at times. But if there weren't limits, I'd hate to see what our policy rates would be otherwise.
Medicare's cap is on hospital days, once those are used up, the rest of care is paid for by the patient, assuming he or she is still alive.
What Obama has to make a case of and here I think he's failing is how his plan is going to be better for the majority of people who currently have insurance.
posted by GLewis on 08/11/09 at 07:08 PM
Page 1 of 1 pages
:: recentcomments
Feb 10, 2012 | 02:12 PMHolland's Gulf of America Bill Sweeping the Nation
DonnaLadd: Thanks, Maddow, for the credit and the link love for this post: on.msnbc.com/yflZ4j
Feb 09, 2012 | 09:50 PM
Biz Roundup: Welcoming New Businesses to Town
redlion: Interesting story. I actually patronized one of Scott's stores during a recent six week stay in the DC area. Still have a re-useable shopping bag from there. Had ...
Feb 09, 2012 | 04:55 PM
[Outlaw] A More Perfect Union
thabian: Loved this column not only for the very important subject matter, but because it contained a truly entertaining voice. I wanted to read more!!!!
Feb 09, 2012 | 04:35 PM
Holland's Gulf of America Bill Sweeping the Nation
DonnaLadd: Let's not forget when Rep. Holland tried to ban abortion back in 2006. Many of us weren't laughing about that stunt. Here's a 2010 report on him and a ...
Feb 09, 2012 | 04:15 PM
Holland's Gulf of America Bill Sweeping the Nation
Jason Meeks: brief mention of it in video :) by Colbert (via Twitter trending) http://tpmmuckraker. talkingpointsmemo.com/201 2/02/mississippi_rep_want ...
Feb 09, 2012 | 04:01 PM
Holland's Gulf of America Bill Sweeping the Nation
DonnaLadd: Oh, and I love it when Mississippi punks the nation.
Feb 09, 2012 | 03:57 PM
Holland's Gulf of America Bill Sweeping the Nation
DonnaLadd: I'm surprised anyone took it seriously. We heard about it earlier the week, and it seemed obvious before it was Holland. But we all deal with him. I'll ...
Feb 09, 2012 | 03:40 PM
Holland's Gulf of America Bill Sweeping the Nation
Lori G: I thought it was genius when I saw it. Of course, I knew the Colbert joke. I think that is the problem. In this state, there just aren't enough people that ...
Feb 09, 2012 | 03:20 PM
Holland's Gulf of America Bill Sweeping the Nation
DonnaLadd: I can totally see Holland on Colbert, both pretending to be conservatives! Ha!
Feb 09, 2012 | 03:16 PM
Fight the Power
rlnave: Attorney General Jim Hood was worried for nothing. Even though he was at the Supreme Court making arguments in the ongoing pardon case this morning, I'm hearing that Jackson Democratic Rep. ...
Feb 09, 2012 | 03:16 PM
Holland's Gulf of America Bill Sweeping the Nation
Lori G: This is an old Colbert joke! I wish someone would send this to Colbert. I swear, I think he'd cover it.
Feb 09, 2012 | 03:02 PM
[Editor's Note] Aloha, Jackson
DonnaLadd: By the way, I looked up an image of the patch our captain friend gave us. Apparently, he is with the 25th Infantry Division; read more here.
Feb 09, 2012 | 01:23 PM
Biz Roundup: Welcoming New Businesses to Town
DonnaLadd: Case in point from the Christian Science Monitor: Whole Foods Killing off Small Natural Food Stores: After years of delivering organic produce to health-food ...
Feb 09, 2012 | 01:19 PM
Biz Roundup: Welcoming New Businesses to Town
DonnaLadd: This is a mixed blessing. They sell cool stuff, but they could shut McDade's and Rainbow down if we're not all careful about where we spend all our food money. ...
Feb 09, 2012 | 01:08 PM
[Outlaw] A More Perfect Union
DonnaLadd: Amazing column.
e-mail newsletter
Sign up for the JFP Daily Newsletter to receive breaking news, local events, music listings and more by e-mail.
just commented on...
» Holland’s Gulf of America Bill Sweeping the Nation 
8
» Biz Roundup: Welcoming New Businesses to Town 4
» [Outlaw] A More Perfect Union 4
» Fight the Power 2
» [Editor’s Note] Aloha, Jackson 2
most recent posts...
» Sunday, February 12
» Metrocenter Moving Forward
» Memorializing Medgar
» Person of the Day: Stuart Kellogg
» It’s the Weekend!
jfp featured event
Jackson 2000 Friendship Ball
Mar 03, 2012 - Civil rights veteran Owen Brooks and Voice of Calvary Ministries president Phil Reed are honored for their racial reconciliation efforts and their contributions to Jackson. Look forward to hors d'oeuvres, a cash bar and music by These Days with Jewel Bass. Proceeds benefit Parents for Public Schools and Students With A Goal (S.W.A.G.). Wear casual attire. more
jfp best bets and recommended
|
Guests online: 222
© Jackson Free Press, Inc. - portions of code by CC with EE. User agreement and privacy statement. |
