home > Noise > Crime> education> Justice> Youth
Cuffs at Capital City?
File photo
by Ward Schaefer
April 27, 2011
Jackson Public Schools is looking into allegations that security guards at the district's alternative school have been punishing students by handcuffing them to chairs, bathroom railings and a gymnasium pole.
The Mississippi Youth Justice Project, an advocacy project of the Southern Poverty Law Center, alerted JPS to the allegations in an April 15 cease-and-desist letter. In the letter, MYJP attorneys Sheila Bedi, Jody Owens and Poonam Juneja wrote that the use of unreasonable physical restraints as punishment violates students' constitutional rights.
"We hope to collaborate with JPS to end these abuses, but we are prepared to file a federal lawsuit to address these issues if JPS is not willing to reform these unconstitutional policies and practices immediately," the letter states.
Staff at Capital City Alternative School regularly use handcuffs to punish minor infractions such as talking back or not wearing a belt, the letter alleges. The letter also enumerates several specific incidents of unreasonable punishment. In one case, a bus driver handcuffed an emotionally disabled student for making a sarcastic remark. In another, a student in handcuffs asked to use the bathroom. In response, an administrator swore at him and grabbed his neck.
Beyond being unconstitutional, restraining children can also be dangerous, the letter asserts, noting that staff allegedly handcuffed students to a pole in the school gym and then left them unattended for hours.
In a letter Monday, JPS attorney JoAnne Nelson Shepherd said that the district "is currently investigating the allegations" and "has also reminded its administrative staff at the Capital City alternative School to comply" with district policy which forbids such punishment.
Alternative schools "perform a punitive function, deterring misconduct and temporarily isolating students who misbehave," the ACLU noted in a 2009 report, "Missing the Mark: Alternative Schools in Mississippi." "But they also serve an important remedial purpose: helping struggling students to succeed, rather than drifting toward dropout and failure. Unfortunately, where alternative schools neglect their remedial role and overemphasize punishment, they may contribute to a nationwide trend, known as the school-to-prison pipeline, toward pushing out and criminalizing students who misbehave."
The ACLU report found that many alternative schools in the state overemphasized punishment and gave short shrift to the part of their mission that called for helping students get back on track.
posted by .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) on 04/27/11 at 09:58 AM. [printer version] Share |
COMMENTS
:: recentcomments
May 24, 2012 | 05:31 AMNick Hanauer's 'Controversial' TED Talk -- Tax the Rich?
Renaldo Bryant: So true. This is why critical and analytical thinking are so important to citizens in a democracy. The rich have the power to shape perception ...
May 23, 2012 | 01:37 PM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
golden eagle: Wow, my English was bad on the previous post. You know how it is on these iPhones.
May 23, 2012 | 12:30 PM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
golden eagle: @Jess, I think the word you're looking for is "assassination". @Darryl, do we really know that the majority of MS'ians wanted this, when you consider that this was a ...
May 23, 2012 | 12:18 PM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
DonnaLadd: I can only hope that the reason that this bill passed is that, for once, our lawmakers listened to the majority of Mississippians and crafted this bill. Considering that the ...
May 23, 2012 | 11:57 AM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
justjess: @Darryl 5/23 "....for once, our lawmakers listened to the majority of Mississippians and crafted this bill." My question is still on the table: What were you "majority ...
May 23, 2012 | 05:26 AM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
Darryl: justjess, I can only hope that the reason that this bill passed is that, for once, our lawmakers listened to the majority of Mississippians and crafted this bill. But, recall, that ...
May 22, 2012 | 04:26 PM
One Night at Fenian's
DonnaLadd: ... because if there is anything The Clarion-Ledger can muster the resources to do, it's show up any night of the week and take drunk pictures. Meantime, they crib our sports stories. ...
May 22, 2012 | 03:53 PM
One Night at Fenian's
Rico: Next time just call Metro Mix at the C-L and have them come and take some pretty pictures for the newspaper. Hell, the got some on karaoke night Monday.
May 22, 2012 | 02:07 PM
[Editorial] To Do Its Job, Council Must Show Up
RobbieR: And Chokwe wants to run for Mayor? Hopefully the citizens of Jackson don't fall for this clown's rhetoric.
May 22, 2012 | 01:15 PM
Catholics Sue Over Birth Control Rule
Brian C Johnson: I cannot decide whether this is a vanity lawsuit, in the sense that the bishops know they stand little chance of prevailing in court. Or to put it more charitably, ...
May 22, 2012 | 01:00 PM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
Brian C Johnson: Darryl, I think it is simply a statement of fact that African Americans in Mississippi are less likely to have the required photo ID. If so, the new law is discriminatory in ...
May 22, 2012 | 11:25 AM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
Duan C.: I am in agreement with Golden Eagle - requiring I.D. ties a fee into voting, the only reason why its considered "discriminatory" towards black, is because it places back into an era ...
May 22, 2012 | 10:22 AM
Person of the Day: Rep. Andy Gipson
RobbieR: What? I was clearly referring to Bennie Thompson, not Rep. Gipson. Rep. Bennie Thomson represents Mississippi's 2nd Congressional district; Darryl noted that he rep'd the ...
May 22, 2012 | 09:59 AM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
justjess: Darryl, out of my "simple ignorance" I ask you this "little question:" Why are registered voters here in the State of Mississippi being asked to produce a picture ID? When the State ...
May 22, 2012 | 08:49 AM
Person of the Day: Rep. Andy Gipson
Duan C.: @ Robbie R - you lost me on that one? They have him listed in the 77th District - covering Rankin, Simpson, and Smith counties?
just commented on...
» Nick Hanauer’s ‘Controversial’ TED Talk—Tax the Rich? 
1
» Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill 16
» One Night at Fenian’s 10
» [Editorial] To Do Its Job, Council Must Show Up 5
» Catholics Sue Over Birth Control Rule 1
most recent posts...
» Friday, May 25
» Michael Duke
» I Don’t Want To Grow Up
» I Want To Stay Young Forever
» The Defense Wears Black
e-mail newsletter
Sign up for the JFP Daily Newsletter to receive breaking news, local events, music listings and more by e-mail.
jfp featured event
Shut Up and Write! 101
Jun 02, 2012 - Sign up for the workshop series of JFP editor-in-chief Donna Ladd's popular non-fiction and creative writing classes. Sessions are from 10 a.m.-12:30 p.m. every other Saturday (excluding July 28) through Aug. 18. Limit of 11 students. more
jfp best bets and recommended
|
Guests online: 207
© Jackson Free Press, Inc. - portions of code by CC with EE. User agreement and privacy statement. |
