home > Sports
[Bryan’s Rant] Full Time Ain’t Magic
by Bryan Flynn
January 25, 2012
I saw several articles last week calling for the National Football League to hire full-time officials after the Green Bay Packers were saved from a fumble against the New York Giants.
To be fair, in my opinion, the referees blew the call, and the ball should have been awarded to the Giants. Green Bay got to keep the ball. The national outcry wasn't needed because, ultimately, New York won.
The NFL is the only major sports league in the United States not to employ full-time officials. The writers screaming for full-time referees believe full-timers would make fewer mistakes.
Before last week's Baltimore Ravens-Houston Texans game, NFL commissioner Roger Goodell said the league would consider making 10 officials full time. This was before the bad calls in the Green Bay-New York game.
I am not against full-time referees, but I am against stupidity. Major League Baseball has full-time umpires, and they still blow perfect games.
In 2010, a blown call hosed Detroit Tigers pitcher Armando Galarraga out of a perfect game. From day to day, umpires' strike zones change, and they miss calls so badly that writers and fans constantly ask for more use of instant replays.
The NBA has full-time referees as well. Basketball fans can relate to watching a game and screaming at the TV over bad fouls and blown calls.
One argument for making officials full time is that it would give gamblers fewer chances to get their hooks into an official. But that has already happened in the NBA. The NBA gambling story is long and drawn out. You can Google it and read about the whole sordid affair. Full-time officials didn't help the NBA stay free of bad calls or gambling.
Some of the top divisions in soccer have full-time referees, and you can't even begin to tell me soccer doesn't have bad calls. In fact, if you were going to write a book on bad officiating, I would start with soccer.
As a sports fan, I hope the players on the field decide games instead of the officials. But I also know that the guys wearing the zebra stripes are human. That means they are going to have bad days and miss calls. Still, it's OK for fans to yell and complain about a game's officiating.
And while it's all right for the media to point out bad officiating, the only way to get better officials is through better training and giving leagues the ability to weed out poor officials.
It is just plain stupid to think making an official full time will make them magically better.
Follow Bryan Flynn at http://www.jfpsports.com, Facebook and @jfpsports.
posted by .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) on 01/25/12 at 05:08 PM. [printer version] Share |
COMMENTS
:: recentcomments
May 23, 2012 | 01:37 PMBryant Signs Voter ID Bill
golden eagle: Wow, my English was bad on the previous post. You know how it is on these iPhones.
May 23, 2012 | 12:30 PM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
golden eagle: @Jess, I think the word you're looking for is "assassination". @Darryl, do we really know that the majority of MS'ians wanted this, when you consider that this was a ...
May 23, 2012 | 12:18 PM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
DonnaLadd: I can only hope that the reason that this bill passed is that, for once, our lawmakers listened to the majority of Mississippians and crafted this bill. Considering that the ...
May 23, 2012 | 11:57 AM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
justjess: @Darryl 5/23 "....for once, our lawmakers listened to the majority of Mississippians and crafted this bill." My question is still on the table: What were you "majority ...
May 23, 2012 | 05:26 AM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
Darryl: justjess, I can only hope that the reason that this bill passed is that, for once, our lawmakers listened to the majority of Mississippians and crafted this bill. But, recall, that ...
May 22, 2012 | 04:26 PM
One Night at Fenian's
DonnaLadd: ... because if there is anything The Clarion-Ledger can muster the resources to do, it's show up any night of the week and take drunk pictures. Meantime, they crib our sports stories. ...
May 22, 2012 | 03:53 PM
One Night at Fenian's
Rico: Next time just call Metro Mix at the C-L and have them come and take some pretty pictures for the newspaper. Hell, the got some on karaoke night Monday.
May 22, 2012 | 02:07 PM
[Editorial] To Do Its Job, Council Must Show Up
RobbieR: And Chokwe wants to run for Mayor? Hopefully the citizens of Jackson don't fall for this clown's rhetoric.
May 22, 2012 | 01:15 PM
Catholics Sue Over Birth Control Rule
Brian C Johnson: I cannot decide whether this is a vanity lawsuit, in the sense that the bishops know they stand little chance of prevailing in court. Or to put it more charitably, ...
May 22, 2012 | 01:00 PM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
Brian C Johnson: Darryl, I think it is simply a statement of fact that African Americans in Mississippi are less likely to have the required photo ID. If so, the new law is discriminatory in ...
May 22, 2012 | 11:25 AM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
Duan C.: I am in agreement with Golden Eagle - requiring I.D. ties a fee into voting, the only reason why its considered "discriminatory" towards black, is because it places back into an era ...
May 22, 2012 | 10:22 AM
Person of the Day: Rep. Andy Gipson
RobbieR: What? I was clearly referring to Bennie Thompson, not Rep. Gipson. Rep. Bennie Thomson represents Mississippi's 2nd Congressional district; Darryl noted that he rep'd the ...
May 22, 2012 | 09:59 AM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
justjess: Darryl, out of my "simple ignorance" I ask you this "little question:" Why are registered voters here in the State of Mississippi being asked to produce a picture ID? When the State ...
May 22, 2012 | 08:49 AM
Person of the Day: Rep. Andy Gipson
Duan C.: @ Robbie R - you lost me on that one? They have him listed in the 77th District - covering Rankin, Simpson, and Smith counties?
May 22, 2012 | 08:47 AM
Bryant Signs Voter ID Bill
bill_jackson: I would be interested to know what percentage of the voting age population does not have identification in this day and age.
16e-mail newsletter
Sign up for the JFP Daily Newsletter to receive breaking news, local events, music listings and more by e-mail.
|
Guests online: 227
© Jackson Free Press, Inc. - portions of code by CC with EE. User agreement and privacy statement. |
