home > Jackblog > ladd

Barbour Compares Health Reform to Jonestown Massacre

Gov. Haley Barbour embarrassed Mississippians again today by standing up alongside several Republican members of Congress and calling the Democratic health-insurance reform "catastrophic," then compared it to Jim Jones' infamous Jonestown massacre, according to a report just out on Politico.

Barbour:

"I've been looking for Jim Jones and where's the Kool-Aid. This is awful, awful policy for our country -- and the people know it. The public already understands this. And the longer the debate goes on, the more the public understands that they're going to end up paying more and that they're going to get lower quality health care. But politically, if the nation can survive it, it will be a political windfall for Republicans."

Politico continued:

California Rep. Jackie Speier (D) said Barbour “should be ashamed of himself, but shame is as foreign a feeling to that man as common sense and intellect.”

As an aide to then-Rep. Leo Ryan, Speier was shot five times and left for dead by members of Jim Jones’ organization. Ryan, who flew to Jonestown to investigate Jones, was killed along with four others on the trip.

"The Governor of Mississippi doesn't have to look at a horrific tragedy in a third world country for comparisons to our country's health care problem," Speier told POLITICO in a statement. "Nearly one third of Mississippi residents between 19 and 29 are uninsured despite his state receiving the most federal health care dollars per capita of any state."


Touché.

Barbour is president of the Republican Governors Association, charged with helping defeat Democrats in states around the country, a role not unlike he played as the head of the Republican National Committee before he moved back to his home state and ran for governor.

 
posted by DonnaLadd on 12/17/09 at 05:34 PM. [printer version]    Share |

COMMENTS

Jonestown, not Jonesboro.

posted by golden eagle on 12/18/09 at 02:35 PM

Edits made.

posted by Todd Stauffer on 12/18/09 at 03:20 PM

Jonesboro, AR did have a massacre of sorts a decade ago when two young boys killed five of their classmates in a school shooting spree. That's beside the point here. You can debate the merits on whether insurance reform is good or bad, but if you have to go to the well of comparing reform to tragedies like Jonestown or the Holocaust, basically, the debater has no legs to stand on.

posted by golden eagle on 12/18/09 at 04:49 PM

The analogy about Jim Jones is unfortunate, yet I must agree with the Governor (for the first time), when it comes to the fraudulent nature of this bill. First of all this is a misnomer, disguised as something dear to our hearts--health care reform; it is actually insurance care-less reform that craftily cloaks itself as being related to our national health deterioration crisis, a crisis that, by the way is not solved by the errant contemporary medical solutions these tax payer funded insurance monies of ours will underwrite, inappropriate medical solutions that end in horrible death, like that resulting from the hole they sawed into my mother's skull to remove a tumor caused by their prescribed Dilantin, or the death to my father (and my brother) by way of the operation on his neoplasmic condition of the pancrease that quickly spread the cancer as their data demonstrated that it would, and the death to my most recent client by way of the Kemotherapy used to remedy the two holes left in her chest where her breasts used to be; all of which come with data proving these treatments do not work to bring about a viable healthy citizenry. If our insurance money is to be used to improve the condition of the American citizen's health, then it should be used to support practitioners and therapies and healing plans that work to rid us of Chronic Degenerative Diseases--this is the real issue. People don't get sick because they don't have insurance, as we are so skillfully led to believe! Power to the Governor on this one!

posted by doctor daddy on 12/23/09 at 03:26 AM

My favorite editorial cartoonist makes Haley Barbour look like Mother Teresa.

http://comics.com/mike_lester/2009-02-18/

posted by jbreland on 01/07/10 at 10:41 AM

It seems to me a "practice in deception" to equate health insurance with an effective nature of viable cure for our health deterioration crisis and dilemma. I see a manipulation of statistics to make this misnomer of an idea behind this Bill fly, particularly, as I have stated, if our tax money is going to be handed over to those whose data demonstrate ineffectiveness to decide what operations and procedures will be used on our fellow citizens (do you think they will opt for the cheapest operations and/or procedures possible?); this is a scary prospect, especially in view of the rash of deaths related to medical treatment and practices in the news today--You know; Michael, Patrick, Isaac, Berney, Brittany, Heath and many many more.

posted by doctor daddy on 01/07/10 at 03:46 PM

Page 1 of 1 pages

You are not logged in. To post a comment, you must be a registered user and logged in. Click here to register or click here to log in.

Log in to JFP using Facebook

:: recentcomments

Feb 10, 2012 | 02:12 PM
Holland's Gulf of America Bill Sweeping the Nation
DonnaLadd: Thanks, Maddow, for the credit and the link love for this post: on.msnbc.com/yflZ4j
Feb 09, 2012 | 09:50 PM
Biz Roundup: Welcoming New Businesses to Town
redlion: Interesting story. I actually patronized one of Scott's stores during a recent six week stay in the DC area. Still have a re-useable shopping bag from there. Had ...
Feb 09, 2012 | 04:55 PM
[Outlaw] A More Perfect Union
thabian: Loved this column not only for the very important subject matter, but because it contained a truly entertaining voice. I wanted to read more!!!!
Feb 09, 2012 | 04:35 PM
Holland's Gulf of America Bill Sweeping the Nation
DonnaLadd: Let's not forget when Rep. Holland tried to ban abortion back in 2006. Many of us weren't laughing about that stunt. Here's a 2010 report on him and a ...
Feb 09, 2012 | 04:15 PM
Holland's Gulf of America Bill Sweeping the Nation
Jason Meeks: brief mention of it in video :) by Colbert (via Twitter trending) http://tpmmuckraker. talkingpointsmemo.com/201 2/02/mississippi_rep_want ...
Feb 09, 2012 | 04:01 PM
Holland's Gulf of America Bill Sweeping the Nation
DonnaLadd: Oh, and I love it when Mississippi punks the nation.
Feb 09, 2012 | 03:57 PM
Holland's Gulf of America Bill Sweeping the Nation
DonnaLadd: I'm surprised anyone took it seriously. We heard about it earlier the week, and it seemed obvious before it was Holland. But we all deal with him. I'll ...
Feb 09, 2012 | 03:40 PM
Holland's Gulf of America Bill Sweeping the Nation
Lori G: I thought it was genius when I saw it. Of course, I knew the Colbert joke. I think that is the problem. In this state, there just aren't enough people that ...
Feb 09, 2012 | 03:20 PM
Holland's Gulf of America Bill Sweeping the Nation
DonnaLadd: I can totally see Holland on Colbert, both pretending to be conservatives! Ha!
Feb 09, 2012 | 03:16 PM
Fight the Power
rlnave: Attorney General Jim Hood was worried for nothing. Even though he was at the Supreme Court making arguments in the ongoing pardon case this morning, I'm hearing that Jackson Democratic Rep. ...
Feb 09, 2012 | 03:16 PM
Holland's Gulf of America Bill Sweeping the Nation
Lori G: This is an old Colbert joke! I wish someone would send this to Colbert. I swear, I think he'd cover it.
Feb 09, 2012 | 03:02 PM
[Editor's Note] Aloha, Jackson
DonnaLadd: By the way, I looked up an image of the patch our captain friend gave us. Apparently, he is with the 25th Infantry Division; read more here.
Feb 09, 2012 | 01:23 PM
Biz Roundup: Welcoming New Businesses to Town
DonnaLadd: Case in point from the Christian Science Monitor: Whole Foods Killing off Small Natural Food Stores: After years of delivering organic produce to health-food ...
Feb 09, 2012 | 01:19 PM
Biz Roundup: Welcoming New Businesses to Town
DonnaLadd: This is a mixed blessing. They sell cool stuff, but they could shut McDade's and Rainbow down if we're not all careful about where we spend all our food money. ...
Feb 09, 2012 | 01:08 PM
[Outlaw] A More Perfect Union
DonnaLadd: Amazing column.

100 recent comments »

 


click to view "flip" version of this week's print issue

 

Guests online: 205
Logged-in members: 2
Anonymous members: 0
Elapsed time: 0.6442
The most number of visitors ever was 1661 at once on 02/10/2012
currently online: Darryl  NatashaBig

 

© Jackson Free Press, Inc. - portions of code by CC with EE. User agreement and privacy statement.
phone: 601-362-6121 (ext 11 sales, ext 16 editorial, ext 17 publisher)
fax: 601-510-9019 * P.O. Box 5067 * Jackson, MS * 39296